Outsourcing medical billing can feel like a lifeline for overwhelmed healthcare practices—but choosing the wrong partner can quietly drain revenue and create long-term risk. In this episode of The Deep Dive, we break down why preventable billing errors alone can cost practices up to 5% of their annual revenue—and why more practice leaders than ever are outsourcing without fully understanding the consequences.
With nearly 36% of practices planning to outsource or automate revenue cycle functions, we walk through 10 critical red flags every practice leader must recognize before signing a billing contract. From hidden fees and lack of real-time data access to rigid workflows, poor EHR integration, weak patient billing experiences, and serious compliance and security risks, this episode explains how small issues compound into major financial losses.
We also explore what a true billing partner should offer: transparency, control, flexibility, strong communication, patient-friendly payment tools, and ironclad security. Ultimately, this conversation is about protecting your revenue, your staff, and your ability to invest in better patient care—rather than letting six figures evaporate due to the wrong outsourcing decision.
Listen now to learn how to spot the red flags, protect your revenue, and choose a billing partner that truly supports your practice.
Transcript
Narrator: 00:00
Welcome to the Billing Blueprint Podcast, your go to resource for innovative medical billing solutions. Each episode we explore the latest industry trends and share proven strategies to help your practice streamline operations and get paid faster. Now here are your hosts, Brad and Sarah.
Sarah: 00:21
Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we are jumping into a decision that is, well, it's really a make or break moment for almost every medical practice out there outsourcing your medical billing. The pitch is always so good, right? They promise to be this lifeline that frees up your staff, slashes overhead, and, you know, finally gets those claims paid.
Brad: 00:41
It's a very tempting promise.
Sarah: 00:43
Yeah.
Brad: 00:43
And it's understandable. The administrative burden these days is just. It's enormous. But the data we've pulled, it shows that choosing the wrong partner doesn't just create a headache, it creates significant, tangible financial loss. Our sources are very clear on this. Preventable billing errors alone can siphon off up to 5% of a practice's total revenue.
Sarah: 01:04
5%. Okay, let's just, let's put that into context for a second. If you're a practice leader listening and you're running, say, a mid-sized clinic doing $2 million a year, 5% is $100,000. $100,000 just gone, vaporized every single year because of issues that are completely preventable.
Brad: 01:20
And that figure, that number should really be the anchor for this whole conversation because the pressure to outsource right now is intense. We saw a late 2024 MGMA stat poll that confirmed a huge chunk. 36% of practice leaders were planning to outsource or automate parts of their revenue cycle in 2025.
Sarah: 01:40
So that means thousands of practices are signing these contracts as we speak.
Brad: 01:44
Exactly. About half said no, 14% were unsure. But the market is absolutely moving. And for those jumping in, they have to know how to separate a real partner from, well, a costly liability.
Sarah: 01:56
Absolutely. So our mission for this Deep Dive is simple. We're going to unpack 10 specific red flags, the things you have to spot before you sign anything. We want you to walk away from this knowing exactly how to protect that hundred thousand dollars.
Brad: 02:09
Let's start with the most fundamental area where trust breaks down first, the money and your visibility into it.
Sarah: 02:15
Okay, so let's start where a lot of practices get burned right on the contract itself. They promise a really low percentage fee. What's the first sign? That promise might be a little shaky.
Brad: 02:24
It's the lack of transparency in pricing. It's the hidden costs that just kill the deal. You sign up for what looks like a Great rate. And then the surprise add on fees just start rolling in. We see it constantly. Vague pricing structures that leave all this room for interpretation. Are they charging you per claim? Is there a monthly minimum? Are they going to charge you just to print and mail a statement?
Sarah: 02:47
Wait, hold on. Charge you extra to print statements? Isn't that, isn't that the core job?
Brad: 02:53
It should be, but if it's not spelled out, it becomes a profit center for them. They can hit you with fees for processing credit cards or a setup fee for data transfer. That was never in the quote. It just erodes any savings you thought you were getting.
Sarah: 03:06
So the takeaway is, if it's not in writing, assume it costs extra.
Brad: 03:09
Absolutely. A good partner defines every single cost clearly in writing. Unclear pricing is a huge signal of dishonesty.
Sarah: 03:18
Okay, so if the money's clear, the next thing is performance. How do you track if they're actually doing a good job? That takes us to the next red flag.
Brad: 03:25
No real time access to your own data. This is so critical because data visibility is power. If the vendor only gives you a static PDF report at the end of the month, you're flying blind.
Sarah: 03:37
You're just reacting to things that happened weeks ago.
Brad: 03:40
Exactly. Imagine trying to fix a leak in your roof, but you only get a report on the water damage once a month.
Sarah: 03:46
By the time you see it, the damage is done.
Brad: 03:48
Precisely. By the time you spot a trend, like a drop in payments from one payer or a spike in small denials, it's already cost you thousands. Real time access, like a dashboard, lets your team spot those things same day.
Sarah: 04:01
That makes perfect sense. So that's when you get the data. But what about what data they give you? Outsourcing shouldn't mean losing visibility.
Brad: 04:08
No. And that leads right into the next financial flag. No reporting on key metrics. If a vendor is just hiding behind some vague, you know, successful collection rate, that's not nearly enough. You have to be able to track the core stuff, charges, payments, adjustments, and critically, your days and accounts receivable days in ar.
Sarah: 04:26
Why is that one so crucial to watch?
Brad: 04:28
Because that number tells you how long your money is just sitting out there uncollected. If your vendor lets that number creep up, you're basically giving a zero-interest loan to insurance companies. Yeah, a lack of transparency here, confusing reports, or them refusing to give you a log into their system, it prevents you from checking their work.
Sarah: 04:47
And the source material we looked at was really clear on one non-negotiable point of control.
Brad: 04:51
It was. You must retain total Control. If a potential partner suggests they'll automatically write off small balances to, you know, clean up the books.
Sarah: 05:01
That's an immediate deal breaker.
Brad: 05:02
Immediate. The rule has to be that no balances get written off without your explicit approval. The moment you give up that control, you're losing money.
Sarah: 05:10
Okay, let's shift from financials to the daily operational grind. This is where outsourcing is supposed to make life easier, not harder. Our next red flag is limited workflow flexibility.
Brad: 05:22
Ah, the curse of the rigid template. This is so common. Billing vendors design their software around what's easiest for them, not what works for your practice. So they try to force this a one size fits all model onto a.
Sarah: 05:34
Specialty clinic, and it just doesn't fit. What does that conflict look like for, say, a practice manager?
Brad: 05:41
It looks like a ton of unnecessary manual work. Your staff is suddenly forced to work around the software, repeating steps, reentering patient info, just using clunky workarounds to file a clean claim.
Sarah: 05:54
And I imagine that goes beyond just inefficiency that's got to affect the team.
Brad: 05:59
Oh, absolutely. It's a direct line to staff burnout and low morale. They feel like they're fighting the system constantly. A good system should adapt to you, not the other way around.
Sarah: 06:09
Speaking of adapting, nothing causes more friction than data that doesn't talk to each other. Which brings us to the next point. No EHR or practice management integration.
Brad: 06:18
If the billing platform doesn't seamlessly connect with your electronic health record and your practice management system, you're just. You're dead in the water.
Sarah: 06:25
Why is that so critical?
Brad: 06:27
Because without it, your staff is forced to enter the same patient information in multiple disconnected places.
Sarah: 06:34
So it's not just an annoyance. It's a huge risk.
Brad: 06:36
A significant risk. Every time they enter that data, you increase the chance of human error. A typo in an insurance id, a mismatched record and a denied claim. And a denied claim slows down the whole revenue cycle. You're hiring an expert to reduce risk, not create new ways for it to happen.
Sarah: 06:55
So what's the standard practice leaders should be looking for?
Brad: 06:58
They need to demand proof of strong connectivity. The best platforms, like the one in our source material, integrate with over a hundred different EHR systems.
Sarah: 07:07
Which brings us to the next red flag. Poor communication and support.
Brad: 07:12
This is where trying to save a few bucks can become a complete disaster. When you have a critical denial that needs a fast answer and all you have is an automated ticketing system, or you're waiting 48 hours for an email.
Sarah: 07:22
It's crippling because every delay is lost revenue. Right? You can't get an answer, you can't file the claim precisely.
Brad: 07:28
Vague replies just cause your internal workflow to grind to a halt. You need quick, accurate answers from someone who actually knows your account.
Sarah: 07:36
So what does a good support structure look like?
Brad: 07:38
You should be looking for a high touch model. Dedicated account managers who know your practice, a clear escalation path, and ideally US based teams who understand the regional payer rules. If you have to explain your practice history, every single time you call that partnership is broken.
Sarah: 07:55
Okay, we've hit the financial and the operational side. Let's pivot to the patient experience. A bad billing experience means bad collections. This leads us to no patient friendly billing features.
Brad: 08:07
The patient financial journey has completely transformed. If your billing partner is stuck in the 1990s, your collections will absolutely suffer. Patients who can't easily understand or pay their bills are just less likely to pay them.
Sarah: 08:20
And we've got some hard data on how much consumer expectations have shifted here.
Brad: 08:24
We do. It's overwhelming. 62% of consumers now say they prefer to pay their medical bills online. And zooming out, 92% of all US consumers used some form of digital payment in 2024.
Sarah: 08:37
So if your vendor only sends out confusion using paper statements and expects a check in the mail, you are creating.
Brad: 08:43
Friction for the vast majority of your patients.
Sarah: 08:45
And you're making it harder for people to pay those big, high-deductible bills.
Brad: 08:49
Exactly. With high out of pocket costs, you need to offer things like patient portals, flexible payment plans, financing options. If the vendor doesn't provide a modern experience, you're actively depressing your own collection rate.
Sarah: 09:01
All right, let's move into the areas that are just non-negotiable compliance and security. The risk here isn't just lost money, it's existential. Red flag number eight, outsourced overseas without oversight.
Brad: 09:14
Right. And while sending work overseas might look cheaper on paper, the risks almost never justify the savings. Offshore teams, they often lack a deep understanding of complex US healthcare regulations, HIP or even specific regional payer policies.
Sarah: 09:29
Which sounds like a recipe for clean denials.
Brad: 09:32
It is. Miscommunication about specialty codes or modifiers is rampant. And beyond that, the security risk is much higher. So many healthcare data breaches happen when offshore vendors mishandle sensitive patient data without proper US level controls. Our source material really emphasized the value of having 100% US based operations for this reason.
Sarah: 09:54
And that sets us up perfectly for red flag number nine. No high pay or security protocols for any practice. This has to Be the ultimate deal breaker.
Brad: 10:03
It must be. If a vendor can't clearly and immediately explain their data protection framework, their encryption, their high P and PCI compliance, you walk away instantly.
Sarah: 10:13
We hear about data breaches, but what's the real financial impact in healthcare?
Brad: 10:17
It's staggering. Healthcare is, year after year the most expensive industry for a data breach. In 2024, the average cost hit $9.8 million.
Sarah: 10:25
Wow.
Brad: 10:26
That's the cost of fixing it. Notifications, legal fees, everything. You have to scrutinize our policies. Do they have a secure backup and disaster recovery plan? Yeah. Your practice's life depends on it.
Sarah: 10:36
Okay, finally, let's talk about the contract itself, the legal document. The last red flag is lock in contracts with no flexibility.
Brad: 10:46
Yes, this is a classic trap. It's used by companies that know their service quality might not hold up over time. So they lock you into these multi year commitments, three, four, five years with huge early termination fees.
Sarah: 10:59
And why is that lack of flexibility so dangerous in healthcare?
Brad: 11:03
Specifically, because healthcare is always changing. Payer rules shift technology changes, your practice's own needs change. A good partner should be able to evolve with you. If they're relying on a restrictive contract to keep your business instead of just, you know, good performance, they're holding your financial health hostage. You should look for shorter terms or performance-based renewals.
Sarah: 11:22
All right, let's take a breath. We've laid out 10 really specific high stakes ways a bad billing partner can derail a practice.
Brad: 11:28
And I think the synthesis here is so important. The biggest risk isn't just one hidden fee or one slow report. It's the compounding effect. When all these red flags exist together. Hidden fees plus delayed data plus a rigid workflow, it just creates an exponential increase in financial exposure. A true partner simplifies things. They minimize risk.
Sarah: 11:50
So let's bring it back one last time to that really painful figure from the beginning. That hundred thousand dollars lost every year to preventable billing errors. Instead of letting that money just evaporate because of a bad outsourcing choice, imagine what you could do with it. That $100,000 could buy that new ultrasound machine you desperately need. It could fund real retention bonuses for your clinical staff to reward them. Maybe it even funds hiring a full-time mental health coordinator for your team. By applying this knowledge, by spotting these red flags and choosing a partner that actually values transparency and performance, you aren't just saving money, you're directly safeguarding your ability to invest in better patient care and achieve the goals that really matter to your practice.
Narrator: 12:31
Thanks for tuning into the Billing Blueprint podcast. For more insights or to dive deeper dive deeper into today's topics. Head over to billflash.com. Don't forget to subscribe and we'll catch you next week with more strategies to keep your practice running smoothly and getting paid faster
Sources: